5. Arts and cultural education
Denmark
Last update: March, 2012
The Ministry of Culture is responsible for most of the higher education and training in the arts. However, as of 3 October 2011 higher education within architecture, design, and preservation, along with the Royal School of Library and Information Science were moved from the Ministry of Culture to the Ministry of Science, Innovation and Higher Education.
Institutions
The higher arts education institutions under the Ministry of Culture include education in theatre, acting, dance, film, art, and music.
The largest schools are the schools of architecture, the Royal School of Library and Information Science and the schools of design, which together account for two-thirds of all students – and which are now under the Danish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Higher Education. The four music academies account for roughly one-quarter, while the remainder of students are distributed among film, theatre, the visual arts, and arts and crafts studies.
All of these institutes have no tuition fees. To be admitted to most of the courses, students have to pass an exam.
Amendments, aims and debates
The Ministry of Culture used to be the main governmental body responsible for arts education and training in Denmark. In the last years the main focus and initiatives have been: 1) to create larger and more viable professional environments, 2) to improve the quality of the training, 3) to improve employment for graduates, 4) to strengthen the international profile of the training.
The focus on increasing employment after training at the higher arts institutes has led to a decision by the Ministry of Culture to lower the number of students admitted to courses as there is concern that too many are being educated for too few jobs. Moreover, the school managements are obliged each year to deliver a report on what the institution is doing to improve the employment of the graduate students. In 2009 advisory boards have also been established, including representatives from the labour market, with the purpose of having a systematic dialogue between the educational institutions and the labour market and thereby developing more opportunities for employment. It is also a goal that the education institutions have to focus on entrepreneurship with the purpose to improve the chances of future employment in the business world.
To improve the profile of the individual institutions, there have been initiatives to raise the quality of education e.g. the yearly budget for the institutions has not been decreased, even though the number of students has. In 2010, several of the institutions were merged to create larger administrative and professional institutions within the areas of music, acting and design. Attracting foreign students to the Danish higher arts institutions is still an important focus area.
The Bologna process has had a big impact on the Danish higher arts institutes. The institutions have introduced Bachelor's degrees and new Masters Degrees. It is also a part of the Danish policy in this area to create international transparency through accreditation and internal quality assurance.
All the courses are expected to follow the developments of new technology in order to prepare the students for the labour market, although there have been no specific programmes.
It is still too early to predict changes in policy relating to the structural changes of institutions between the Ministry of Culture, and the Ministry of Science, Innovation and Higher Education. However, a recent report from February 2012 (Internationalisering ved de kunstneriske og kulturelle vidergående uddannelsesinstitutioner) that focuses on the internationalisation of educational institutions within the cultural and arts sectors indicates that this is a prioritised area. The content of the report builds on data from the period 2007-2009 and does therefore not take recent structural changes into account. The report is, all the same, a valuable document in terms of the role internationalisation plays in the policies of institutions of cultural education. The report recommends that specific strategies of internationalisation will be made, that a specific code of conduct will be developed, that the institutions within cultural and artistic education develop a language policy that these institutions align with national strategies on internationalisation, and improve in terms of branding and marketing. Furthermore, these institutions are encouraged to send their students abroad, to establish focused agreements on international cooperation, to document information and progress within the area and create sustainable networks.
The situation regarding art education in schools has been widely debated since The Danish Arts Councils report "Spænvidder" ("Spans - about art and culture") was published in September 2010 (can be downloaded from http://www.kunst.dk).
The debate has been centred on how the teaching of art in the Danish school system can be further developed and improved. Are children educated in art by doing making art themselves? Or should they be educated through teaching in art-history, art appreciation, art theory etc. What are the effects of the two sides of arts education in schools?
These kinds of questions draw on various art educational traditions and understandings, as expressed in the Anne Bamford Report The firebrand in the Classroom, which operates with a distinction between teaching in the arts and education through art. (Anne Bamford: The firebrand in the Classroom. A Review of Danish Arts Education Schools, the Arts Council Copenhagen 2006. (https://www.kunst.dk/db/files/the_ildsjael_in_the_class_room.pdf)
Art training can therefore aim at an objective of imparting aesthetic experience and insight about art for "passing heritage on to young people". In this case, priority in teaching art in schools focuses on selected works, traditions and forms. The others tradition in arts education will seek to "allow them [the young] to create their own artistic language and contribute to their overall development - emotional and cognitive". (Anne Bamford: The Wow Factor. Global research compendium on the impact of the arts in education. Waxmann, New York / Munich / Berlin 2006).
The Danish Arts Council’s Music Committee works to ensure a large and diverse range of school concerts. In 2009 the Committee launched a survey of school concerts. The findings can be read in the report School Concerts in Denmark published 2010 (can be downloaded from http://www.kunst.dk).
The organisation Live Music in Schools has been appointed as the key player in funding school concerts.
Last update: March, 2012
New review of artistic development in higher arts education: Following the Ministry of Culture's research strategy and multi-year agreement for higher artistic education 2006-2010 – a working group was appointed in 2010 chaired by the Ministry of Culture to prepare a statement of artistic development for educational institutions.
The Working Group, in January 2012, completed particular proposals for a definition of "artistic development", as well as charts for the activities of the institutions and proposed a number of recommendations for activities within the artistic development.
Artistic development is part of the knowledge base in higher arts education in Denmark and representations provide for an increased focus and better structuring of this area.
Cultural Minister Uffe Elbæk commented:
"This investigation may help to enhance the professional identity of artistic education by articulating and conceptualising what artistic development is and can be. This allows for professional development to become more analytical and precise and useful for students and academic environments. It is positive that the proposed framework points forward and is in line with international developments in the field"
Minister of Education Morten Østergaard stated:
"The report clarifies a key intersection for the arts education programmes under the Ministry of Culture and architecture and design schools. This training sits on three legs - the artistic, scientific and practical. I am sure that the recommendations of this report are good tools for enhancing artistic development and highlight this as an important resource. (Download the publication for higher artistic education development at https://www.lkca.nl/~/media/downloads/bijeenkomsten/dutch-scandinavian%20exchange/denmark.pdf)
Last update: March, 2012
The basic out-of-school arts education for children and youth up to 25 years in Denmark is for a large part provided by the 99 music schools placed in the 98 municipalities in Denmark (one in each municipality except for one which has two). At the same time you will find about 50 additional art schools located throughout the country that offer both music and other creative subjects. Furthermore, there is also an unknown number of private drama and dance schools and private teachers who offer arts tuition and a large number of publicly supported amateur associations and educational art projects, e.g. in museums or art institutions, focusing on both teaching basic skills and developing talent. Finally, arts education is taking place as part of the curriculum at some of the "efterskoler" (a unique Danish kind of independent residential school for students between 14 and 18 years).
The basic-out-of-school arts education for adults is for a large part private and based on student fees, however, there is also publicly supported arts education for adults taking place at Open Education Evening Schools in amateur arts associations or at Folk High Schools.
Music education in music and cultural Schools
The main governmental support for the basic out-of-school arts education for children and youth from 0-25 years of age is given to the teaching of music taking place in the music and cultural schools, thus reflecting a prioritisation of this art form by the state.
The governmental support for music schools and music in cultural schools is given both through budget approbation and through a state refund of salaries and transport for leaders and teachers. Besides this, the music schools and music in the cultural schools are financed by support from the municipalities and student fees.
In 2010 the music schools received DKK 89.6 million (EUR 1.2 million) from the budget approbation and DKK 679.2 million (EUR 90.6 million) in refunds of salaries and transport. The municipalities contributed the sum of DKK 484.7 million (EUR 64.6 million) and the students paid DKK 195.3 million (EUR 26.0 million).
The development in the official figures during 2006-10 shows a drop in the state support from 14.25% to 13.32%, despite a rise in the expenses for transport and salaries that was compensated by a rise in support from the municipalities and in the student fees.
This is the main reason behind a growing concern, among music schools and their organisations, for the running of music schools, especially as the support from the municipalities is under pressure from the global financial crisis.
The worry is that the increase in student fees ultimately will make less "well off" parents opt for other and cheaper leisure activities for their children and that some children will grow up with very little or no knowledge of music. This concern increases as the formal school system is characterised by a decrease in lessons spent on music and arts related subjects. The worry is not without justification as there has been a drop in music school students from 102 242 in 2005-06 to 87 624 in 2009-10. (All figures are from the “Rapport om musikskolevirksomheden 2006-10”, published by Kunststyrelsen).
Interestingly enough, the development coincides with a governmental focus on the need to strengthen talent development in the music schools outlined in the Ministry of Cultures Music Action Plans for 2004-2011: ”Liv i Musikken 2004-07” and ”Nye toner 2008-11”. This priority is allocated DKK 5.75 million (EUR 767 000) for such initiatives at music schools. This focus might explain why the decrease in the number of students in the music schools is not followed by a similar decrease in the number of lessons given or the amounts spent on salaries or transport. In other words, the interpretation might be that music schools are prioritising fewer students learning more - as opposed to having many students. But the development could also be a reflection of the fact that the number of music schools in Denmark fell from 216 to 99 after the structural reform of local government in Denmark in 2007, thus creating longer distances between music schools. In continuation of this the main themes in the music school debate at the moment concern the following:
- the balance between talent development and a more participatory approach to music;
- the need to strengthen co-operation between the formal education system and music schools;
- the need for programmes aimed at getting more children to attend music schools;
- the need for programmes aimed at attracting students to the less popular instruments;
- And how to reduce the waiting lists for popular instruments like guitar, drums, piano and singing.
After attending a music school, the next step for a gifted student will often be to enter the “MGK – musikalsk grundkursus” (i.e. basic music course), a three year music programme financed by the state budget. This programme is targeted at young people aged 14-25 years and aims at educating talented musicians who can inspire the local music environment and prepare students for a higher music education at one of the five conservatories. In 2010 state support for the MGK programme amounted to DKK 37.4 million. During the period 2005-2008, a pool under the above mentioned Music Action Plan directed another DKK 3.0 million per year to the MGK programme - as a way of compensating for the stagnation in public support when the state took over (from the disbanded counties) due to the structural reform in 2007.
The other art forms and the alternatives to music and cultural schools
Besides music schools, there are quite a few publicly sponsored art schools in Denmark targeted at children from 0-25 years of age, specifically for painting / drawing or drama / dance. They get their funding from a variety of local and private sources: Some are paid for by student fees, some are under the auspices of municipalities, some are run by art museums and some are organised as associations receiving support for their activities from the Act of General Education. This is the case for many “dance schools” which are often in reality associations with status as a sports activity.
Along with the art and music schools there are also examples of state financed institutions such as The House of Dance that receives public support for time limited projects or programmes aimed at both basic art education and talent development for children and youth and examples of the "efterskoler" that offer a range of creative subjects such as circus, media and dance. These educational programmes are sponsored by a mixture of support from both state and municipalities channelled through the Ministry of Education - plus student fees.
Out-of-school- arts education for adults
Finally there is also out-of-school- arts education for adults taking place in amateur arts associations, open Education Evening Schools or at Folk High Schools. This education is primarily financed through the General Education Act that sets the general conditions for the municipal support to adult education or else involves private tuition. You can get further details about this in chapter 6.4 on Amateur Culture – but it is worth mentioning that public support through the General Education Act since 2002 has been hit by severe cuts of around 45%.
In conclusion it must be added that it is difficult to get a complete overview of the entire range of ”out-of-school-arts-education” in Denmark outside music as this field is generally left to the commitment of municipalities and private initiatives and is very differently organised and funded. The general notion in the latter years is, however, that the field is under pressure primarily due to the global financial crisis.
For further information on out-of-school arts education for both children and adults see: http://www.boernogkultur.dk, http://www.dansenshus.dk, http://www.kunst.dk, http://www.damusa.dk, http://www.dmpf.dk, http://www.hojskolerne.dk, http://www.efterskoleforeningen.dk.
Please find the available information on this subject in 5.3.